3

It looks like has the same meaning as . Perhaps we don't need both of them.

Question: What's the difference between [classifiers] and [measure-word]?


Bump: Now I have a diamond, I believe I can just make a synonym of instantly. (I.e., keep .) Any objections?

| |
  • no objection lah 😸 just to remind you, there’s one more tag “quantifiers” with 1 question, what to do? – 水巷孑蠻 Jul 15 at 1:41
  • If it's just one question, it can be retagged to [measure-word] manually. Although, I'm not 100% sure that it has the same meaning. However, it's probably similar enough that the distinction doesn't matter. – Becky 李蓓 Jul 15 at 1:46
  • "status-planned" => I intend to do it, but I don't want to rush into it as it's not an easily reversible change. – Becky 李蓓 Jul 15 at 23:10
  • I feel whoever is reading this will likely want to see: What's the difference between classifiers and measure words? – Becky 李蓓 Jul 20 at 12:58
2

Vote for merge.

The usage info for says:

Classifier, or Measure Word, is a word or morpheme used along with numbers and countable nouns to denote the quantity of a given object, represented by a noun.

which suggesting that they are the same.

Also the wikipedia page for mesure word has such an introduction:

This article is about measure words in general. For measure words in Chinese, see Chinese classifier. For measure words in Japanese, see Japanese counter word.

which also suggest they are the same thing in Chinese.

| |
2

I proposed a tag synonym to make (25 Q's) a synonym of (41 Q's). My impression is that "measure word" is a more familiar term.

*** This needs votes here *** or nothing will happen. It's a useful synonym.

The questions tagged are:

  1. [update 15 July 2020] Purpose of the reduplication in 一步一步地往上爬

  2. Nouns that don't require a measure word

  3. How to say "this" in "This is my third time in Taiwan"?

  4. How to correctly use "多" to say "more than"?

  5. The classifier 一把for 手機

  6. Classifier choice for 荚谜

  7. Is classifier/measure word required after demonstrative?

  8. Where to put the adjective when asking for something that comes in multiple sizes?

  9. 个 ge usage plus 每 mei

  10. What classifier imply a volume?

  11. What's the correct classifier for `房子`?

  12. Is there a difference in meaning between 那年夏天 and 那个夏天

  13. List of classifiers for Cantonese?

  14. 條 or 個 as classifier for road (路) in Cantonese?

  15. Purpose of duplicating measure words?

  16. When to use "下一个" and when just "下一" to translate English "next"?

  17. Which term and which counter to use when ordering simple meals?

  18. Why is 汉子 measured in 条?

  19. Is there any authoritative works related to measure words?

  20. Measure words for disrespect

  21. Measure word usage with 这个/那个

  22. Classifiers for rooms

  23. Which classifier for window (窗户) is regularly used?

  24. Syntax of 'Number Number MeasureWord'

  25. Why 回 is used in 回事 instead of 件事?

  26. Learning how to use measure / count words properly

Some of them even use the term "measure word" in the title.

| |
  • 1
    I'm sorry, I do not have the required score on this tag to vote for this tag synonym :( – dROOOze Feb 5 at 11:50
1

Okay, I merged them, and changed the tag wiki (feel free to edit this to something better):

For questions about measure words and classifiers (量词), e.g., 个, 双, 张

I'm confident that few people (if anyone) will object to me merging these tags. I feel it's clear from the examples that they're used interchangeably. However, I don't know for sure whether to call it or .

For now, I'll choose because:

  • I feel beginners are often taught that 个 etc. is a measure word, so they're not going to think to use classifiers, however...
  • I spoke with Tang Ho about this, and (assuming I've understood things correctly) some people are instead taught that 一个 is a measure word in which 个 is the classifier (this may even be the linguistically "correct" terminology). Nevertheless, the people who understand this distinction can probably understand using as an approximation for for the purposes of tagging.

Basically, it's my best guess at the time of writing. If the community thinks is better, it's easy to rename (but please create a meta post).

| |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .